Medical Malpractice Lawyers

Study Confirms Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Attorneys’ Suspicions: Abuse Underreported

As nursing home injury attorneys in Cleveland, we realize that nursing home injury is actually a lot more common than most people think. Many cases go unreported. Sadly, this suspicion has been confirmed in two new government studies.

Conducted and published by the Office of Inspector General of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the research found that in most cases of abuse or neglect severe enough to require medical attention, the incidents have not been reported to enforcement agencies — despite the fact that it’s the law.

One study focused on nursing home residents who end up in nursing homes. Nearly one in five cases were not reported to police.

“Some of the cases we saw, a person is treated in an emergency room [and] they’re sent back to the same facility where they were potentially abused and neglected,” Gloria Jarmon, deputy inspector general for audit services, told NPR.

Elder Abuse Can Happen Anywhere

And elder abuse can happen in multiple settings — not just nursing homes. A second study looked at medicare claims for the elderly regardless of where the incident took place. Nearly one- third of the incidents were not reported to law enforcement.

That’s why it’s so important to work with a nursing home injury attorney in Cleveland. All too often these tragic incidents are merely swept under the rug and ignored.

Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Attorney: 3 Lessons Learned from the Vegetative Patient Who Gave Birth

What can we learn from the tragic case of the nursing home resident in a vegetative state who gave birth? Our Cleveland nursing home injury attorney had a few thoughts.

A Clean Record Does Not Guarantee Safety

The 36-year-old suspect, Nathan Sutherland, who police say has DNA that matches the baby, had a clean background check, a spotless record, and a clear license to practice. And yet he is alleged to have raped the patient who he was charged to care for. It’s heinous and tragic, but a clean and spotless record for staff does not necessarily mean a patient is safe from assault.

Health Checks are a Must

Hospital staff did not even realize the patient was pregnant until she gave birth. How could this happen? The facility did not keep up with necessary healthcare checks. Even when a patient is in a comatose state, regular healthcare and checkups are important.

Rape is Rape

A woman in a vegetative state cannot consent. Yes, she was sexually assaulted, but more specifically she was raped. Tragically, sexual assault is all too prevalent in nursing facilities, often committed by the very people responsible for the care of our loved ones.

Do you suspect mistreatment of your loved one? Call Linton Law Firm today and schedule a free consultation with one of our nursing home injury attorneys in Cleveland.

Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Lawyers and the Sad Effects of Boomerang Elderly Care

“Oh my God, we dropped her!” That’s something you never want to hear from your nursing home aide. That’s the kind of situation that leads to lawsuits being filed by a nursing home injury lawyer in Cleveland.

When aides dropped Sandra Snipes, she happened to land on her right side where her hip had recently been replaced. Snipes had suffered from a myriad of medical problems that had her going back and forth between nursing home and hospital, a trend that has become not uncommon.

A Sad Story with Even Sadder Statistics

“One in 5 Medicare patients sent from the hospital to a nursing home boomerangs back within 30 days, often for potentially preventable conditions such as dehydration, infections and medication errors, federal records show,” NPR reports. “Such rehospitalizations occur 27 percent more frequently than for the Medicare population at large.”

Unfortunately, nursing homes have traditionally benefited from this trend since both hospitals and nursing homes received financial benefits from such transfers.

“There’s this saying in nursing homes, and it’s really unfortunate: ‘When in doubt, ship them out,’” David Grabowski, a professor of health care policy at Harvard Medical School, told NPR. “It’s a short-run, cost-minimizing strategy, but it ends up costing the system and the individual a lot more.”

It’s a sad phenomenon that leads to more cases being filed by nursing home injury lawyers in Cleveland. It’s a system in badly need of reform, leaving many patients in its wake.

Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Lawyer: Lack of Adequate Staffing Increases Risk Injury

One surprising reason nursing home injuries are so shockingly common is not incompetence or ill intent. In fact, one of the biggest reasons negligence has become so prevalent comes down to inadequate staffing. It is a tragic trend that nursing home injury lawyers in Cleveland understand all too well.

The numbers are shocking and concerning. Of the nursing assistants who responded to a survey done by The Plain Dealer, 83 percent said facilities, where they worked, were always or frequently too short-staffed to meet residents’ needs. Nearly half of the 81 percent claimed to have worked back-to-back shifts at least once a week because of short staffing.

A Dangerous Job

One reason for the short staffing is a lack of adequate pay and lack of qualified applicants, especially in a strong economy where jobs with better pay and benefits are plentiful. The shortage is dangerous not only to residents but to the staff as well, which places further stress on the caretakers, making the job even less desirable and positions harder to fill, creating a vicious self-perpetuating cycle.

“I’ve never worked as a lumberjack, and I’ve never worked in the mines, but [working as a nurse’s assistant] is absolutely one of the most dangerous jobs out there,” said Genevieve Gipson, the executive director of the National Network of Career Nursing Assistants, told the Plain Dealer. “I have yet to find anyone who works with patients in the long-term care industry who doesn’t have some form of an injury.”

Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Lawyer: Abuse Cases On the Rise

It’s a startling trend that certainly troubles our nursing home injury lawyer in Cleveland. Since 2011, staff to resident abuse in long term care homes has risen 148 percent, according to a  year-long CBC Marketplace investigation.

In 2016, there were 2,198 reported incidents of abuse pointing to an average of six seniors at long-term care homes in Ontario being abused every day.

While the data was compiled from a six year investigation in Ontario, similar trends can be found in the US, especially Ohio.

Nursing home abuse is surprisingly common.

“We hear stories of people being illegally detained, of being left in bed for days, filthy conditions, cockroaches, assault,” Jane Meadus, a lawyer and institutional advocate with the Advocacy Centre for the Elderly, told CBC News.

Why Evidence is So Important

And often when families do inquire about the nature of injuries, they receive little information or help from care staff. Many in response have turned to placing cameras, to monitor their loved ones.

“Every time we’d ask for an explanation from the facility, we would be told that there was no documentation, there’s no information to elaborate or to clarify or shed light on what occurred,” Daniel Nassrallah, a Canadian lawyer representing a client who suffered nursing home abuse.

That is why our Cleveland birth injury lawyer always recommends documenting any possibility of elder care abuse. Take photos, have the resident examined by a doctor, even collect camera footage if necessary. Your loved ones safety, health and rights deserve advocacy.

Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Lawyer: Ohio Ranks Among Worst in Elderly Care

It’s a sad fact that’s well known to our nursing home injury lawyers in Cleveland. Ohio ranks among the worst in the nation for elder care.

A new report from the Scripps Gerontology Center at Miami University found that Ohio ranked below the national average on all 10 of the quality measures used by the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services, including instances of urinary tract infections, unexplained weight loss, pain, pressure ulcers and use of antipsychotic medications. The study looked at residents who stay in a facility for 100 days or more.

The Record Courier reports:

“The numbers show that the percentage of patients using antipsychotics went from 23.18 percent in 2013 to 21.59 percent in 2017, though the 2017 national average is 18.46 percent for antipsychotics and the 2013 average is 19.85. The best state, which was not identified in the report, had less than 9 percent of patients on the drugs in 2013.

Antipsychotics are often given to people with dementia, which can be dangerous, said Beverly Laubert, Ohio’s long-term care ombudsman. Her office is working on helping professionals try non-pharmacological approaches to dementia care.”

That’s why our nursing home injury lawyer in Cleveland always takes the allegations of his clients seriously. Our state certainly has encountered problems with the quality of care we provide our seniors in the sunset of their lives.

Ask a Nursing Home Injury Attorney in Cleveland: Why is Ohio’s Care so Bad?

It’s a sobering yet logical conclusion for any nursing home injury attorney in Cleveland: Why do Ohio’s nursing homes rate among the lowest in the nation when it comes to quality care, as measured by federal statistics?

Simple. There’s just not enough staff.

“Almost always, we had to work short-handed, handling anywhere from 15 to 20 people at any given time,” former nurse’s aide Lolly wrote in a Cleveland Plain Dealer anonymous survey of the state’s caregivers. “It is impossible to give proper care to that many people, answer the call lights and be everywhere at the same time.”

The Results? Tragic…

Not having enough hands on deck can cause extremely dangerous accidents that easily result in tragedy. As one sad example, Susanne Lawrence, a resident of Normandy Manor in Rocky River, overdosed after being given 20 times the prescribed dosage of oxycodone, or 500 milligrams. Staff failed to read the medication’s label and the 83 year old died after her last dosage on July 7, 2015.

Deadly Math

The statistics and the extent of the crisis are shocking, even for a nursing home injury attorney in Cleveland who deals with them every day. After three months of research, the Plain Dealer discovered:

• “Nearly 41 percent of the facilities in Ohio earned a below-average rating of one or two stars on the federal Nursing Home Compare standard, as of Dec. 1, compared to 35 percent nationally.
• At least 31 Ohio nursing home deaths in the last three years were attributed by authorities to issues of care. Residents’ lawyers argue the number could be far higher, because they depend upon self-reporting by nursing homes.
• Ohio’s minimum staffing rules are relatively lenient. Facilities in the state are required to make available 2.5 hours a day of nursing staff time for each resident. Florida and California require much more.
• Ohio requires only 75 hours of training for the aides who provide much of the care in a nursing facility. California requires 150 hours.
• Many states have given themselves the ability to fine nursing homes that violate “their standards. In places like California, state fines are used to strengthen nursing home inspections. Ohio doesn’t fine nursing homes. Instead, it recommends a dollar amount to the federal government, which sets and collects the fines. A portion of the fines is returned to the state.”

If you have a loved one in a residential care facility in Ohio, talk to a lawyer to ensure they are getting the best care. If statistics are any indication, their quality of life, if not their very lives themselves, may be in your hands. Contact us for a free consultation.

A Win for a Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Attorney: Abuser Gets 18 Months

Any dedicated nursing home injury attorney in Cleveland understands that feeling when their clients get the justice they deserve.

Such is likely the feeling of the legal team of Edward McShaffrey’s victim. The 59-year old was sentenced to 18 months in prison for sexually abusing a nursing home resident. A licensed practical nurse at Brookdale Montrose Nursing Home, he was seen with his mouth on the victim’s private body part. The victim suffered from Parkinson’s Disease and suffered from communication difficulties.

The nursing home immediately fired McShaffrey following the incident. He had worked at the facility since 2004.

“We appreciate the jury’s effort in seeking justice for this case. This situation saddens us deeply because having the trust our residents and their families is extremely important to us,” Heather Hunter, senior public relations assistant for the facility, told the Plain Dealer. “This type of conduct or behavior by an associate is never tolerated by us under any circumstances. Our thoughts are with the victim today.”

Sadly, it is a story our nursing home injury attorneys in Cleveland see come across their desks every day. The victims, due to limited communication skills or cognitive abilities, have far too few resources to turn for help. They need a voice. That’s why the Linton Law Firm is here for you. Call us today for a free consultation.

Medical Records Suspicious? Talk to a Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Lawyer

As any nursing home injury lawyer in Cleveland can tell you, a nursing home’s medical records can’t always be taken at face value. If the staff has something to hide, their documents may have been forged, altered or otherwise not true.

In Chicago, two social workers claimed they were fired because they refused to falsify medical records related to incidents of nursing home patient abuse at the former Burnham Healthcare, now known as Bria of River Oaks.

“There was no structure. It was dangerous,” one of the social workers, Kenneth Allen, told the Chicago Tribune.

Documents Missing or Falsified?

Allen alleges that when he documented a resident’s rape complaint, a supervisor ripped the report from the medical file and tore it up.

Allen also claims he was told to falsify another patient’s medical report to look like she had fallen, when she very well may have been assaulted.

State investigations, meanwhile, indicate that the facility indeed had committed several instances of abuse.

From the Chicago Tribune:

“A 2012 state inspection report said two residents alleged guards beat or roughed them up in separate incidents. The report says that at least one guard at the home was fired as a result.

State inspectors have cited the facility for abuse-related incidents after Ogunyipe and Allen were terminated.”

So if your family member references abuse or injuries not mentioned in their medical file, don’t just take the word of the facility. Talk to a Cleveland nursing home injury lawyer. There may be abuse which needs investigating.

Cleveland Nursing Home Injury Attorney: Trust Your Elders

This unbelievable story from the desk of our Cleveland nursing home injury attorney has two heroes. First, the Columbus nursing home resident who took it upon himself to call 911 despite the fact that his nurses didn’t believe him when he said he felt ill. Second, the firefighter who, despite the reluctance of the facility’s staff, decided to send a dispatcher anyway to see what the problem was about. Thanks to their efforts, the nursing home, the fire department, and especially the nursing home residents and their families, “dodged a bullet,” Battalion Chief Steve Martin told the Columbus Dispatch.

The resident, identified only as “Mr. Jackson,” told the 911 dispatcher, “Nobody wants to believe me that I’m not feeling that good.” Mr. Jackson wanted to go to a hospital.

The dispatcher asked to speak to the man’s nurse, who qualified it as “a behavior thing” that “happens all the time.”

But that dispatcher decided to listen to the resident and  send paramedics instead.

“There was nothing that set it apart from any other call,” Firefighter and dispatcher Brian Severs told the Columbus Dispatch. “Something told me, ‘Don’t blow this off; this person called 911 because they thought they needed help.’”

Gut Instinct = Lives Saved

It turned out to be carbon monoxide poisoning. The entire building had a gas leak. “Mr. Jackson” and Severs saved the lives of 143 residents.

Granted, the elderly members of our family are at the sunset of their lives, so it’s understandable when we take what they say with a grain of salt. But learn to trust them and trust your instincts. If you ever have any concerns, contact a nursing home injury attorney in Cleveland. Indeed, our elders just may be trying to tell us something we need to hear.